Skip to main content

 

Silent Stories of a City

Houses hold stories in their walls – of family meals, getting home work done, friends visiting, scribbles on the walls, and the inevitable quarrels. There is a great sense of loss as buildings are pulled down. It is as if lives are sent to some no man’s land, to exist as shadows, soon to be dismissed as fanciful imagination.

Watching homes tumble like flimsy cardboard structures in the recent flash floods across the world was a shocking reminder of the vulnerability of man’s claim on the earth. Family albums, carefully collected furniture and favourite clothes are turned into muddy rubble. Wars and natural disasters are seen as forces beyond the control of people. Some homes are abandoned as families disperse, some are erased by developers who only see property value instead of cherished homes.

Karachi’s streets are being stripped of their history. Karachi was the Dubai of the late 19th century, for the most part, bare sandy tracts upon which architects, supported by local Silawat builders, could experiment with architectural styles - Venetian Gothic, Indo Saracenic, Art Deco and later on, 60’s modernism.

Walking  or driving through the inner city of Karachi, exquisite buildings of the past are sandwiched between thoughtlessly constructed concrete buildings. Yet one’s eyes are transfixed to these quiet sentinels of a graceful past. Who stood in their balconies, their spacious verandas, climbed their teak staircases?  What did they view on the streets below?

What was Jayashankar Madhawji’s life like in the house designed by M. Nazareth on plot No 34 and 34/ A, in Market Quarter?  Or that of Noorbhoy Jafferji who lived up the road at No 81 in a house designed by Jamsedji P. Mistry? What parties were held in the beautiful residence on 82 Bunder Road with its romantic grapevine carvings?

While the buildings fall like ninepins under the demolition squad, the streets still bear witness to Karachi’s eclectic population. In just one area of Ranchore Lines, Solomon David Road, Ali Budha Street, Shivdas Street, Vishan Das Street, Mir Ayub Khan Road and Kalyan Jee Street are bounded by Nabi Bux Road and Barnes Street.

Cities are always changing and growing, facing increasing pressure to provide new housing and business centres. While Karachi’s town planners develop layouts of streets and zoning, and the Building Control Authority are tasked to ensure the engineering soundness and space usage of new constructions, there seems to be no attention paid to the aesthetic integration of the old and the new.

Developers, calculator in hand, are determined to ensure the maximum sellable covered area, arriving at box like structures built with the cheapest materials in the shortest possible time. There is no room for the graceful arched verandas of Mohatta Goods Godown on Mission Road, or the exquisite detailing of the Mohammad Ali Building in Moosa Lane.

It is not simply nostalgia for the past. A study by environmental psychologist, Colin Ellard, revealed that monolithic, dull facades found on modern skyscrapers and apartment blocks were found to cause stress to passers-by and inhabitants. These are not buildings that encourage intimacy, a sense of belonging and pride. The anonymous sameness devalues inhabitants, who scurry up and down dark uneven stairs to get to their box like offices or homes.

Preservation and revitalization of heritage localities plays a large part in cultural resilience. It is a way of being cradled by previous generations and an inspiration to carry the story forward.

Trader Seth Bhojomal saw Karachi’s potential in 1729 and the East India administrator, Charles Napier, believed it could be the Star of the East. Mayor Jamshed Nusserwanji Mehta ensured it became the cleanest city of Asia.

The old city, approximately 50 sq km, a fraction of the larger 3,780 sq km area of Karachi, is waiting for loving attention. Many organisations and individuals have done their best to highlight and protect Karachi’s heritage. NED university’s Heritage Cell, Arch Arif Hasan, Yasmin Lari’s Heritage Foundation, Arch.Marvi Mazhar, heritage walkers Shaheen Nauman, Jehanzeb of Super Savari Express, Farooq Soomro, the Karachi Walla, countless researchers and photographers have worked tirelessly to protect the 1700 declared heritage buildings. The Sindh Cultural Heritage Preservation Act was passed in 1994. Yet they all seem helpless before the juggernaut of developers and land mafia.

A new directive has been issued by the Chief Minister of Sindh to assess the condition of listed buildings in the city. There is no conversation about setting up engineering teams to specialize in their restoration instead of delisting and demolishment. European heritage buildings destroyed during WWII were reconstructed from existing plans. Today new technologies like Lidar scanning can document heritage buildings in great detail, and pave the way for the true preservation of Karachi’s heritage.

Durriya Kazi

August 9, 2025

Karachi

durriyakazi1918@gmail.com

 

 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Decorated Trucks of Pakistan

International Institute for Asian Studies / Association for Asian Studies / Asia Committee, European Science Foundation First International Convention of Asia Scholars Leeuenhorst Conference Centre, Noordwijkerhout , Netherlands , 25-28 June, 1998 Panel: “ Shaking the Tree: New Approaches to Asian Art” / Session: Decorated Transport Decorated Trucks of Pakistan Durriya Kazi June 1998. Karachi Meaning is always in process, what has been called “a momentary stop in a continuing flow of interpretations of interpretations”. This paper pauses at some facts and some observations about decorated trucks of Pakistan , a subject that has elicited tantalisingly few studies. Pakistan is often presented geographically and thus historically as the corridor of land between the mountain passes that separated the near East from the plains of India . Less mentioned and more significant is its identity as the valley of the River Indus which has historically ...
Post a Comment
Read more
    The Ink of the Scholar   The ancient Greeks were the masters of philosophy and science for over 1000 years. The Agora of Athens which once resounded with the discussions of Socrates, Plato, and Sophocles is silent and empty today with broken pillars covered with weeds.   Rome once ruled the Mediterranean and beyond, but today is associated with Italian cuisine, fashion and art in the shadow of the ruins of the dreaded Colosseum where Roman emperors were entertained by gladiators fighting to the death.   That is the trajectory of all civilizations that reached great heights and then tumbled into fragmentation, their past glory all but forgotten.     The Islamic civilization too was once the most significant custodian of learning, and like the Greeks, many of its inventions, philosophies and laws are still an integral part of modern societies.     Unlike the Greek and Roman empires, the achievements of the Islamic empi...
Post a Comment
Read more
Choosing to Study Art and Design Another academic year is about to begin. The number of young people wanting to study art and design is growing. Young people in Pakistan seem to know something that parents and policy makers do not. Subjects that will materialize into successful jobs are usually identified as medicine, IT, business studies, and engineering. School and college curricula channel young people in these directions. For the last five decades, education has been serving economic development, and public policies reflect this. The term “human capital” developed by economists Gary Becker and Jacob Mincer in the 60s, is overused as an aim to produce labour capable of increasing economic  growth. But as we know youth has its own recalcitrance, and as society’s elders are less and less able to guarantee pathways to success, there is a growing urge in young people to plan life journeys on their own terms. Along with business school, computer sciences and pharmac...
Post a Comment
Read more