Skip to main content

Beyond Gender

Earlier this month, two extraordinary women were in the news: Fahmida Riaz, the poet, whose death was mourned by many and SP Suhai Aziz Talpur, whose triumph was celebrated by proud Pakistanis when she was at the forefront of the operation against the terrorists who attacked the Chinese Consulate in Karachi.

While many feminists may celebrate them, they represent a far more complex space that cannot be contained in a traditional gender discourse. 

Fahmida Riaz said in an interview with fellow poet, Amar Sindhu “I am not an exceptionally politically over-charged poet. Perhaps the only exception is that I am a woman.”  She has translated into Urdu Rumi’s Masnavi, the poetic works of Shah Latif Bhittai and Shaikh Ayaz, written about a range of political and social issues. However, her public perception is imprinted with her 1978 publication     Badan Dareeda in which she  shared her sensual awakening. She says she did not set out to shock but merely expressed as she always has  “the relationship between the life and works of a writer” 

Are we saying  SP Suhai Aziz’s leadership in the Chinese Consulate operation was  impressive because the threat was quickly  and efficiently contained,  or are we impressed that she achieved this despite being a woman? Her determined no nonsense manner reflects her belief that “jobs are not gender specific”.   Her male colleagues and superiors  put faith in her abilities rather than her gender.

History is filled with remarkable women that fought for the rights of women  - Emmeline Pankhurst’s suffragette movement,   Germaine Greer’s Obstacle Race,  and Betty Friedan’s  Feminine Mystique  to name a few.

However, there is also a large number of women whose motivation to achieve   their goals had little to do with their gender such as Rosa Parks who refused to give up her seat to a white man on a  city bus in USA, or Hypatia  in 4 C  Egypt and  Lubna   in 10 C Andalusia who were respected teachers of  mathematics and philosophy.

A substantial list of women inventors and scientists is finally surfacing : Lisa Meitner’s discovery of nuclear fission in the 19C , Marie Curie’s theory of radioactivity, Actress Hedy Lamarr’s work in wireless communications  which made the cellphone technology and digital communications of today possible. Stephanie Kwolek’s invention of Kevlar  used for bulletproof vests of  soldiers and law enforcement officers all over the world. Well into the 20C, it was still found necessary to create the Girl Geek movement which grew out of  the realization that there were many geeky nerdy women who were as obsessed about technology as men.

Women warriors have existed in almost every age and in every nation.  Some were formed into women’s armies such as the Greek era  Amazons of Anatolia, the Amazons of Libya,  the African Dahomey Amazons of the 17-19C  , the  500 strong Turkish women archers and the 500  Abyssinian swordswomen employed by Ghiyasuddin Khilji,   and the 18C women’s army of Rani Velu Nachiyar.
Individual female warriors – Boudicca, Joan of Arc, Razia Sultana, Rani of Jhansi, Chand Bibi, Khawlah bint al-Azwar, and Sayyida al Hurra of Morocco, or the Vietnamese Lady Triệu, fought at the command of or side by side with male warriors. Women also took part in wars as  individuals such as the female Samurai, Nakano Takeko,  or  Noor Inayat Khan, Indian spy for the British in WWII.

It is not men who are threatened by strong or independent women but “society”, which includes both men and women, that wants to preserve the continuity of past social structures.  As the systems scientist Peter Senge says   “People don't resist change. They resist being changed.” 
 
Durriya Kazi
November 26, 2018

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

https://theconversation.com/at-once-silent-and-eloquent-a-glimpse-of-pakistani-visual-poetry-70544 ‘At once silent and eloquent’: a glimpse of Pakistani visual poetry February 13, 2017 6.55pm AEDT Author Durriya Kazi Head of department Visual Studies, University of Karachi Disclosure statement Durriya Kazi does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond the academic appointment above. Partners View all partners Republish this article Republish our articles for free, online or in print, under Creative Commons licence. Rickshaw poetry in Pakistan.  D.Kazi ,  CC BY-NC-ND   Email   Twitter 33   Facebook 239   LinkedIn 1  Print Whose mischief created a world of beseechers? Each petitioner is seen wearing a garment of paper This line from the famous Mughul poet  Ghalib  refers to what he claimed to be ancient Per
Art and the Swadeshi Movement In my quest to discover the origins of the exquisite tiles in my aunts’ home in Karachi’s old Amil Colony, I stumbled upon a whole new dimension of the Swadeshi, and later Swaraj, movement, an important rallying point for the Freedom Movement. Swaraj is commonly identified with Non-cooperation, Civil Disobedience, and political rallies. Behind the public bonfires of European cloth, manufacturers, designers, artists, poets and journalists quietly built factories, established presses, redesigned art school curricula that not only spread the spirit of revolution across India but ensured there were locally produced alternatives. Jamshed Nusserwanji established Bharat Tiles with Pheroze Sidhwa in 1922 in Bombay with a manufacturing branch in Karachi, as his swadeshi contribution, saying “India needs both economic and political independence”.     Developing a new process using coloured cements, the exquisite tiles we see in all heritage buildings i

Portrayal of Women in Pakistani Cinema

PORTRAYAL OF WOMEN IN PAKISTANI CINEMA Talk at Arts of the People IV “Lollywood- Pakistani film posters” Fukuoka Asian Art Museum 2006 By Durriya Kazi Many of you will not have seen Pakistani films. So I will first explain the style. Like Indian Films, they are all musicals. The songs are very a important part of the film and sometimes the most memorable part. A very ordinary story can be a box office hit if it has good songs, while a good story without good songs may be a flop. The songs are not sung by the actors but by a playback singer who is sometimes more famous than the stars, such as Madame Noor Jehan, who has sung for films for 50 years, like India`s Lata Mageshkar. Along with songs dance is also an important ingredient, but maybe not as important as in Indian films which have really fantastic dances. In fact I know someone who fast forwards the dialogue and just watches the dances of Indian films. If you see them you will know why! The films are